Labour’s Equality Bill lets down gay employees

Islington has been at the forefront of gay rights campaigning, including the first gay rights demonstration – led by Young Liberal Louis Eakes – on Highbury Fields nearly 40 years ago.

Just last week I was having coffee with a supporter who first joined the Lib Dems because of our pioneering record, championing gay, lesbian and transgender rights when these weren’t the mainstream issues they are today.

The world has changed for the better. This year I was one of thousands dancing through the sunny streets at London Pride. Civil partnerships are a real breakthrough we should all welcome. But homophobic bullying and hate crimes are still a reality. And so is employment discrimination.

Labour likes to trumpet its record on gay rights. But now the EU is threatening the Labour government with a European court order and possible fine, because they are breaching EU employment equality laws, by allowing organisations to discriminate against gay employees on religious grounds.

This is bad news for employees and also for faith groups, who once again get unfairly characterised as prejudiced extremists. The reality is that most faith groups are responsible, liberal employers. Gay rights issues are a divisive issue within faith groups, not between faith groups and the rest of society.

EU law is not about taking the faith out of faith organisations. In a pluralistic society that would be unacceptable. EU employment law rightly allows religious organisations to apply a reasonable requirement based on religion. So faith schools could require some or most teachers to be of that faith. (Although when St Andrew’s CofE school, where I’m a governor, appointed our new head, we followed the ‘Christian dentist’ approach: when you have a toothache, do you go to a good Christian, or a good dentist?)

Faith groups should not be allowed to discriminate on the grounds of sexual orientation. And indeed under EU law they are not. But the UK Government is resisting this. Our local Lib Dem MEP Sarah Ludford has highlighted Labour hypocrisy on this issue. As she says, “It is extraordinary that Harriet Harman’s new Equality Bill does nothing to remedy this continued illegal discrimination, which would have warded off Brussels action. Her bill indeed seems to be more about gestures than real change.”

5 Comments »

  1. […] the original post: Labour's Equality Bill lets down gay employees « Bridget's Blog By admin | category: gay | tags: first-joined, gay, last-week, mainstream, memphis, […]

  2. Jen said

    “pioneering record, championing gay, lesbian and transgender rights” …and indeed championing equality for bisexuals too.

    But yes, “Labour’s” record of delivery on LGBT issues can more accurately be ascribed depending on the issue to either the Lib Dems or Europe. Civil partnerships, section 28, age of consent, adoption, military ban, GRCs… time and again Labour had to be pressed into doing the right thing. They spent heaven knows how much money defending the military ban through the courts – and now try to claim the credit for repealing it after they lost!

  3. […] more from the original source: Labour's Equality Bill lets down gay employees « Bridget's Blog AKPC_IDS += "4557,";Popularity: unranked […]

  4. bridgetfox said

    More from Sarah here: http://www.concept-team.ch/2009/12/15/letters-dismayed-by-failure-on-anti-gay-prejudice/

  5. […] Read the full post here. […]

RSS feed for comments on this post · TrackBack URI

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s